A leader is someone who helps others understand what they want,
and then helps them get what they want. Lucky followers! I want
my leader! A bit of an oppsy should I turn out to be a leader, helping
others at sizeable personal cost, for public domain leadership in
the ultimate analysis is about sacrifice and the act of giving.
Not so in the worlds of trade, commerce and industry where to the
victor belong the spoils of war.
The corporate warriors of Islamabad, Lahore and Karachi were beneficiaries
of a two-day practice based Workshop that provided learning and
development solutions to busy managers. Led by Ethics Campaigner
Ramiz Allawala, and facilitated by the new TCS division geared to
providing hands-on learning to management cadres, the Workshop on
Integral Leadership brought together a good cross-section of the
corporate world that included senior functionaries of the Central
Board of Revenue Mr. Zafar Aziz Osmani (Member CBR for Human Resource
Management) and Mr. M. S. Lal (Member CBR for Personnel & Training).
In an effort to become user-friendlier the CBR is leading from the
front a stepped-up interaction with present and potential taxpayers.
Search For Missing Links
Identifying learning needs, establishing focus and sharing perspective
were themes that Ramiz started with to probe the Workshop participants
and get them started. Handling a large group of forty plus was a
heroic undertaking that Ramiz undertook with a fair amount of dexterity,
splitting the participants into six teams. Areas of concern were
soon identified, and amongst them were negotiating with greater
confidence, resource and time management, conflict resolution, how
to carry a team and motivate without force, identifying and filling
leadership gaps, managing change, grooming successors, evaluating
people, becoming an ideal human being, gaining acceptance as a leader,
managing bosses effectively, and how to inspire others.
Trust, The Heart Of Ethics; Ethics,
The Heart Of Leadership
Trust is the central issue and major means for generating integral
leadership, and it begins with trusting the process, and not getting
ahead of the game. Trust is defined as believing that words mean
what they appear to mean, and experiencing actions that are consistent
with the verbal or written message. Well being and material growth
is based on trust, with high trust cultures yielding prosperity
and progress. Trust doe not build randomly. It requires the investment
of time and energy. The absence of trust leads to fear, greed and
polarisation, with the language of the human spirit replaced by
the language of machines that can be manipulated.
Distrust yields needless wondering about negative outcomes and wandering
in unproductive directions. Authentic trust is based upon engagement
through closure, with US multinationals cited for tight closure
that enables clockwork execution. Closure being defined as agreement
between two or more parties on the way ahead.
The Trust Model
The Trust Model comprises Closure, True Promises, Non-violent Communication,
Respect For All, and Authentic Responsibility. It is much better
to under-promise and over-deliver than over-promise and under-deliver.
Fear leads to over-promising and distrust, which leads to more fear.
It feeds on itself and leads to destruction. Trustworthiness equals
the sum of Credibility, Reliability and Intimacy divided by Self-Interest.
When Self-Interest is zero Trustworthiness rises to infinity. Organizational
Trust equals the sum of Aspirations, Abilities, Actions, Articulation
and Alignment divided by Resistance.
The function of a team leader is to ensure maximum participation
from team members and achieve consensus of opinion. An interesting
exercise followed in which each team listed their perception of
Pakistani and Non-Pakistani ways of motivating people effectively,
dealing with poor performance, improving sense of urgency, handling
conflicts between subordinates and staff, and persuading staff to
accept change. The findings castigated the Pakistani way as inferior.
We appear to know the right way, but the prevalent culture of scepticism
and cynicism prevents us from doing it right, driving us to chose
the easy way out. We need to be value driven, with the belief and
practice of our values natural to our functioning. A value must
be chosen freely, prize, and protected.
Considering The Other's Viewpoint
There is not enough empathy, and an absence of humanistic and rational
approaches in Pakistan. The greatest gift that we can give another
is our presence. There can be no correction without connection.
Man is a natural problem solver, but we must first establish connection
by understanding the issue before trying to solve the problem. The
moment we start intellectualising and analysing we stop empathising.
Empathy is emotional first aid. At funerals we find the Curiosity
Cats, those who probe for details of the death and asset distribution;
the Educators, who try and instil the new burden of responsibility
upon the survivor(s); and the Connectors, who console with their
presence and non-invasive inquiry about the needs and feelings of
the aggrieved, wait for the shift when the burden of sorrow lightens,
and then guess the post-emphatic request if any.
Patience And Compassion
Psychotherapy is nothing more than good, clear and honest communication
that lies very much within the scope of leadership. 'Humdardi' requires
a lot of patience and compassion. These findings came out while
tackling four case studies that Ramiz had distributed on Integrated
Leadership. Then there was Mr. Haroon the Marketing Manager's case
study that dealt with climbing the ladder of inference and the jumping
to conclusions. The advice here was not to assume or pre-judge people,
and refrain from creating stereotypes that lead to adversarial relationships.
Less Is More
In yet another exercise crucial Western and Eastern concepts and
skills were compared, and the initial reaction was of Capitalist
versus Humanist. Upon re-examination it was found there existed
striking similarities once the Eastern terminologies were rationalized.
However, the Western Model was found to be paying a heavy price
in terms of environment, ecology and family ties.
Search For Self-Esteem
Threat and reward, stick and carrot are a universal approach to
managing people. What differentiates us is our lack of subtlety.
Pakistan lacks organizational structure, with the mindset playing
an important role. The central issue is one of trust, and in Pakistan
we don't trust our handlers. How we balance the ideal with ground
reality determines the level of our self-esteem. The power of the
context often prevails, with cultural forces more powerful than
individual forces. People who have been colonized invariably suffer
from low self-esteem. The search for silver linings must prevail
with the positive sought out in every situation. Structures, policies
and procedures are tools for dehumanisation and yield low trust
cultures. Values can't be taught or changed. However, a willingness
can be created to learn or change.
"Yanta Lagen"?
Self-esteem equals Success divided by Pretension. The higher the
success and the lower the pretension, the higher the self-esteem.
The people of Finland practice a concept called "Yanta Lagen"
wherein they deliberately seek to have less than their neighbours.
A case of keeping-up-with-the-Joneses in reverse. The Finnish took
it to such an extreme that it resulted in clinical depression. Trying
to emulate and live up to an image can become pretentious, so long
as one refrains from pomposity. However, timeless and ageless power
develops from within the individual, empowering through conviction,
and is not dependant upon external sanction. Goals that are inconsistent
with values are never achieved.
A Question Of Relativity
We need to move away from the concept of right and wrong to a concept
that classifies actions as useful and less useful. 'Wrong' attracts
retribution, and retribution retards relationships. Choosing between
right and wrong is the easy part. The dilemma arises when we are
confronted with a right versus right choice, between the individual
and the community, long term versus short term, truth versus loyalty,
and justice versus mercy.
When everyone's needs are met there is no aggression. The scarcity
of resources has never been a problem; it is their inequitable distribution
that makes for conflict. As long as wrongness exists the conflict
will not be resolved. Moenjodaro was a superior and sophisticated
civilization, one in which everyone's needs was met as testified
to by a complete absence of weapons amongst the relics that have
been excavated.
The No-No Of Presentations
Group One didn't quite meet the deadline for completing the exercise,
and their penalty called for the singing of a song! Which they did,
rather than miss tea. During the presentations Ramiz pointed out
a few pitfalls that need to be avoided. Avoid the vocalized pause!
Become conscious of when you say "eeeerr" while fishing
for thoughts, and break the habit. Silent pauses are more dramatic.
If you put your hands in your pocket, ensure that you don't have
coins or keys in them! Or else you'll be tempted to jingle them
and lose focus. Avoid apologies. Leaders don't apologize! They rationalize
and learn while accepting responsibility. That's called micro-managing
the route to integral leadership!
Summarizing Pre-lunch
Protect the dignity of yourself and others, protect the self-esteem
of yourself and others, and don't sit judgement were the central
learning of the pre-lunch session. It was noted with great alarm
that the word dignity does not appear in the Constitution of Pakistan.
The central purpose of life is to support life, and not destroy
it. Reward and punishment will get mere compliance, lacking in enthusiasm.
The choice is between aggression and assertion, competition and
collaboration, militancy and non-violence. The modern US corporate
structure has its roots in the military.
O Suzy Wong!
Suzy Wong was her usual hospitable self, and the fried prawns,
chilli beef and exotic chicken were memorable indeed. The battle
of the bulge continues, and I tried to balance the second helping
of the main course by staying off the desert! Always works. Who
wants the puddings anyway! Such is life, In the midst of strife,
Talking of which, I gotta call the wife! Shouldn't sound too satiated
when I do, Or the broom will descend, Even as I pretend, That the
food was all wrong, At Suzy Wong! Suzy who?! She'll ask, Even as
I the burp do mask, Who've you been making out with? In the middle
of the day, She'll thunder! As I stutter and stammer, And wander
and wonder! She's not a she at all! I'll profess lamely, Ready as
ever to surrender tamely, Even as memory lingers, Of the exotic
Suzy Wong!
Being Pushy!
Post-lunch, and the hunger pangs got substituted with slumber pangs,
even as Ramiz turned up the juice with a discourse on assertive
behaviour and the international business model. The hard sell, the
sell or perish syndrome exemplified by the doctrine of conspicuous
consumption. Assertive training goes on since childhood, and it
is important to distinguish between assertion and aggression. The
goal of self-leadership is diminished if we don't assert ourselves.
Family Affairs?
Nepotism came up for discussion next, with the 'talented cousin'
under fire. Recruiting family members compromises organizational
success. There is no example worldwide of an international brand
built by family business. No three generations have succeeded each
other in a successful business.
Day One of the Workshop came to a close with a discussion of varied
protocols to handle Impasse, improve Advocacy and Inquiry, and situations
where one is in disagreement. There was homework to be done overnight
in the form of preparing a real life workplace presentation that
one would be doing in the near future.
DAY TWO
The second day began with a recap of negotiation skills, with primary
importance being given to the inquiry technique whereby the needs
of the other party could be accurately ascertained. The rest of
the day was dedicated to the preparing and making of presentation
outlines.
Smart Objectives
The presentation objectives should be clearly outlined, and should
be Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant and Time Dependant.
The title of a presentation should be shortened until it doesn't
make sense! And then moved up one level where it makes sense, and
that should be the length of the title, and no more. Presentations
should have an Introduction, main Body, Recap and Closure.
Presentations Galore!
Thereafter followed forty-three presentation synopsises ranging
from the cancellation of a channel contract to how to say no to
a customer, how to be a good corporate citizen, case for three shifts,
return on investment of training, gold the perfect investment, new
system for implementing environment management, getting up in the
morning, turning dreams into reality, and so on and so forth.
Recap & Closure Lacking
Overall Ramiz appeared impressed by the confidence with which the
participants spoke, and he ventured to comment that we might have
discovered a goldmine of orators here! However, a common failing
was in the areas of recap and closure. Body language, decibel levels,
and the enthusiasm with which the audience was approached and addressed
were also commented upon under a system of peer evaluation. The
participant got assessed separately by Ramiz as well, and was handed
his or her assessment sheet at the end of his or her presentation.
The Delectable Suzy Wong
Once More!
It's that time of day, When the appetite holds sway, That lady
of the East, Will provide us a Feast, Yesterday she had me briefly
in trouble, Buried under the rubble of misunderstanding, Today is
another day, And this morning we have had enough food for thought!
Thank you Ramiz for distinguishing between right and wrong, But
for now, Onward to Suzy Wong!
Not Much Has Changed
No sooner had lunch ended and prayers offered that Ramiz was once
again in full battle cry! Leadership skills required in the 21st
century haven't changed much since the 3rd century. Build trust,
and look after the morale of the troops is the mantra today, as
indeed it was yesterday. Money does not motivate, and financial
incentives are good for closure.
The Arithmetic Of Change
Multiplying Dis-satisfaction with Vision and Knowledge equals Change,
and this should be greater than the Psychological, Political and
Financial costs incurred in bringing about that change. Trade-offs
can be End-based, Rule-based, or Care-based, with the rule of reciprocity
applying.
Managing time is an important contributor to success, and important
things that remain unattended for a period of time will assume an
urgency. Planning, Training and Delegating are three ways to avoid
things from becoming urgent.
Eliminating negative tactics through the appreciative inquiry technique,
as propounded by Cooper and Sri Vastava, will solve problems without
the need to solve problems.
BRAVO TCS!
Ramiz distributed Certificates of Participation at the end of it
all, but not before he had reflected for a bit upon the significance
of that day, the 31st of December, and the manner it had been deployed
in the pursuit of Integral Leadership. The new year would bring
ample opportunity to put theory into practice, and reap the rich
harvest of good governance.
TCS, said Ramiz, has moved from the delivery of documents to the
delivery of knowledge, moving from costly tangibles to priceless
intangibles. He sensitised the participants to the TCS role of good
corporate citizen, since the cost of organizing these Workshops
far exceeded the price of participation. This brought forth a round
of applause that developed into a standing ovation.